Friday, November 6, 2020

Review: Gardens of the Moon

Gardens of the Moon Gardens of the Moon by Steven Erikson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Anyone who follows my reviews will know that I read under typically unfortunate circumstances. I have many kids and little time. I've mostly been on a reading sabbatical, which as a reviewer I deeply regret. Therein lies the question of why I decided to start the Malazan series as a way to bring myself back to form. Especially with everything I have against me.

You see, Malazan is considered to be a "difficult" series. I talked with multiple people shortly after I started as to figure out why this is, and it came down to a few reasons. The main, of course, is that it suffers from the same illness many fantasy series do. Unusual names for people & places mixed in with tons of worldbuilding. The Malazan series is incredible with its worldbuilding. Erickson excels in it.

The short prologue sets the story up a little bit but takes place many years before the events of the rest of the book. Once you get into the first chapter you are treated to rapid pacing and information dumps relentlessly. There's probably close to twenty characters or more that you meet in the first two chapters and they aren't the entire cast. Nothing in this book is done on a small scale. Those information dumps are purely all over your lap, your hands, the floor. I've been told to "get" the Malazan Series you would have to study it. Seriously, that was my advice. The only way it was going to work was to commit my all to it. Well, that didn't happen. And you shouldn't worry about that either.

The book starts us out with possession, then a massacre, an investigation, and an important battle. What could be troubling is that during these events, little things may be occurring that get referenced but don't come fully to light until afterward. Gardens of the Moon makes you wait for the payoff. What slowed me, in the beginning, was keeping up with all the names, titles, and places thrown at me so quickly because the book does not stay put. It jumps from characters and situations frequently. Enough to make me want to write down who is who and what they are doing, whose side they are on? No. I did grow annoyed when people had multiple titles or nicknames and those were used interchangeably without mentioning their actual name but that is only really prevalent in the first part of the book. Also, I'm still not sure how many one-armed people exist.

All of this changes once the first battle ends. We've met a good portion of the major characters or else heard about them and the format of the book abruptly changes. The pacing slows. We spend a decent amount of time with fewer characters and then move on to the next big set-piece. Or course, once there we get a whole boatload of new characters and more things occur but it's like hearing the same story but told by someone else. This shift happens in Chapter 5 so if you are on the fence about sticking with it, make it at least through that chapter.

I was very impressed with Erikson's ability to merge stories and connect his large cast. I call this the Tad Williams quality I look for in authors. Some people can do it, some people can't. Tad always wins. Erikson doesn't just give us a story but a rich history of the world with different species and cultures too. I have the full collection of books to go through and I know a lot of things mentioned in this volume will come up again and be expanded. It's a series that you can get lost in and even live in for a while to escape from everything going on in our world.

I'd seen somewhere that Fiddler was a favorite character for his humor but I didn't notice Fiddler that much in this book, and never for a laugh. I enjoyed Captain Paran as well as Crokus and the rest of his crew. Adjunct Lorn also grew on me throughout the book. Curiously, with the first two, they are the closest we get to generic fantasy hero tropes. I'm talking about a stable boy or kitchen hand. Paran was a noble that decided when he was a boy that he'd rather be a Soldier. Crokus is the nephew of a known writer (and more) who can land himself in the higher circles of society but chooses to be a thief. With a cast so large it's odd that I find the two easiest characters to enjoy, but they also are used as pawns to the Gods (one in particular) so the focus is largely on them. Lorn then is someone who struggles between her duty as the Adjunct who exists solely as the hand of the Empress and the person she is. The more I think about this the more I realize how I enjoyed many of the characters. Excellent job Erikson.

The main plot focuses on the Malazan Empire planning to conquer the city of Darujhistan which is secretly run by High Mages and has rival Assassin clans. An Assassin War is a minor part of the book. Complicating the Malazan Empire's plan is Anomander Rake who is the lord of the Moon's Spawn which is a floating fortress with a city within it. He had made a pact with an earlier city, that of Pale, where the first battle of the book takes place and jumpstarts the events. Despite being opposed to the Empire, Rake ultimately comes across as a third party. It's team A versus team B but team C is involved because so and so. Got it. He has his own cards he is playing in Darujhistan, and everything comes together as books do.

I enjoyed the ambivalence of the characters. Although you can say a couple of people do things only to deliberately harm others, actions are often brought about because of the situations they find themselves in. Those I swore were the villains turned out not to be so at all. Even the Gods we meet, because they play huge roles, are typical Gods. I would compare them closest to the Greeks. They come, they interact, sometimes they help, sometimes they ruin things, and then off they go. It's like watching episodes of Xena with more interesting immortals and a lack of lesbian undertones. Mmmm Calypso.

The worldbuilding was impressive but not entirely my thing. On a geographical scale, I didn't mind it. When we dive into the history of non-human races, the first inhabitants of the world, etc, I start zoning out. Rake, who in Gardens of the Moon is 20,000 years old, is a Tiste Andii which is similar in appearance to a Drow. Dark skin, white hair. His people have a backstory as they are one of the elder races and I wasn't able to connect with them. At least at the time of reading. Now that I'm done I do appreciate more their storyline. There are also the Imass, the K'Chain Che'Malle, the Jaghut, and others. Each with details enough to fill a companion textbook. I just wanted to keep moving with the story, getting to the top of the figurative mountain without doing the climb. This is me as a person and not a fault of Erikson. It's a lot of information but none of it is hard to understand.

What I'm getting to is that if you are interested in the series but hesitant, I recommend you try it out to at least the end of chapter 5. Don't do a ten-page in and skip thing. This is involved fantasy to the fullest extent and you will be rewarded, I promise you. Read on a kindle to avoid papercuts. Ten big books mean lots of opportunities.

View all my reviews

Friday, September 18, 2020

Review: The Return

The Return The Return by Roberto Bolaño
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

A series of person tragedies punctuated by a book I was looking forward to but ended up hating led me to take a sabbatical from reading. Its been difficult, the long road back to myself. Luckily, Bolano was there waiting. I don't know what will happen when I finish all his works. I try to save and sprinkle them throughout my reading stack. Maybe the world will end. It feels like that sometimes.

I read but didn't review The Romantic Dogs because I am not comfortable enough to have any specific views on poetry. Though I also try to stay away from short story collections, I owe it to Bolano to speak up. So, without beating around the bush anymore, here are my thoughts on The Return.

Snow - A story is told by a man whose family fled Chile due to them being Communist. They end up in Russia and he becomes a procurer for a Russian Mobster. One of the girls that the mobster wants is a gymnast who ends up in a side relationship with the narrator. Its kept hidden until one day the girl reveals the truth to the mobster who ends up beating the narrator but lets him live. It turns out to be a bad decision because our speaker then kills the mobster and leaves Russia. This isn't a favorite of mine from this collection but I've noticed other people refer to it among theirs. It IS a very easily identifiable Bolano story.

Another Russian Tale - A quick little story about a WW2 Soldier in a Spanish Division who is wounded, discharged, and accidentally sent to the wrong division. While it's being sorted out, the German division he is with gets captured and he is discovered by Russians. They torture him but the language barrier is proving difficult to confess his innocence. Eventually, they try to pull his tongue with pliers and he shouts the word "Cunt" but to their ears, it is "Kunst" which means Artist. Thinking he is an Artist, they end up letting him live, and eventually when the war ends he goes on with his life.

William Burns - An American is hired to look after two women who insist they are being stalked by a serial killer. He believes he found the guy per the instructions given to him by the women and ends up kidnapping the man's dog. The guy comes to the house and is murdered by the American. Later on, the American is killed. It's unclear, at least to me, if the man was a stalker, to begin with. The American doesn't seem to believe so at the end. He thinks it was a case of mistaken identity. I had the feeling that maybe the women intentionally misled him. Maybe the man was an ex-lover. They were very quick to start disposing of the body. I don't think a man looking for his dog would break into a house the way he does. Maybe this is all obvious to everybody else.

Detectives- A conversation between two detectives which ends with one of them recounting a story about Arturo Belano in jail. We've seen the other side of this story in another form, in another work. The back and forth between the detectives take a while to get us to the actual story here.

Cell Mates - The story of a man who begins an open relationship with a woman who is crazy. Both of them are former prisoners. I didn't take notes but I believe in this one the woman and one of her boyfriends try to murder a friend of the narrator.

Clara - Another relationship story. The girl develops cancer. In the end, she disappears.

Joanna Sivestri - A Porn Star does a shoot in Los Angelos. She visits an old friend, a former porn star, who is dying. It's clear he has AIDS but Joanna sleeps with him anyway which, knowing how the crisis was responded to in the early '90s, pulls me out of the story for lack of believability. Unless the point was she just doesn't care.

Prefiguration of Lalo Cura – Lalo Cura makes many appearances in Bolano's work. This story is about his mother being a porn star while pregnant with him.

Murdering Whores - A whore narrates. She kidnaps a man she's seen on TV and is about to murder him. If you notice at this point the stories tend to have a narrative running through them all.
The Return – The best story in the collection and one of the strangest and funniest Bolano ever wrote. A man has a heart attack while out dancing and dies. He recounts how he hated the movie Ghosts, especially the scene when Swayze first leaves his body, but that is exactly what happens to him. He follows his body to the morgue and is hanging around without direction until two workers take his body with them. The body is sent to the home of a famous Fashion Designer who doesn't sodomize it but gets off on it. Then our Ghost speaks and the Designer hears. After proving that he is the ghost of the deceased and not a hidden speaker, he decides to stick around with the designer even when his body is retrieved by the workers. An unlikely friendship has developed.

Buba - The story of a Soccer Team with bad luck. The narrator is a player who is injured in or before his first game. He ends up rooming with Buba who is an African. One night, Buba tells our narrator and another man on the team if they give blood to him he can guarantee a win. This starts a cycle that lasts all season and beyond. Buba always scores two goals, with the remaining going to them. Eventually, Buba is traded to another team and they end up beating the team the narrator was on. The book ends with the team, sans Buba, reuniting for a documentary. Buba had died in a car crash earlier on.

Photos - Arturo Belano looks at photos of poets and thinks about who he wants to have sex with.

Meeting with Enrique Lihn - Bolano, as himself and not Belano, has a dream he meets the very much dead Enrique Lihn who tells Bolano he admires him. There's also a case of double mistaken identity on the steps of Lihn's building which is an amusing step away from the main story.

How Bolano writes humans is what makes his work special. I can't think of one American author who captures our essence in quite the same way. How Bolano tells stories, and how he has his characters tell each other stories, is so distinct. There is a deeper emotional richness. Even lighthearted conversations have heavy undertones and that's what sticks out to me. Bolano is like an English Teacher's wet dream in that regard.

What did I think of The Return?
As with any Short Story collection, I like some more than others. My favorites would have to be The Return and Buba. The other stories were more commonly fitting with Bolano's style and that worked against them here. The Return and Buba were uniquely different and showed a side of the author I wish we got to explore more of. I have a mental block of Cell Mates and Clara beyond them being two very similar stories. The non-romantic in me could be the catalyst behind that one. Bolano is at his best when he writes these lost or broken people. As a collection, I like how the themes flow from one story to the next but the stories about porn stars and whores disengaged me. I'm not a prude. Trust me on that one. The first porn-related story was ok. I'm not interested in these people but moving past the sex there's a poignant story. Then the Lalo Cura story came. I think out of all Bolano's characters, Lalo Cura is someone I'm never big on. The Murderous Whores story was better, in a different sort of way, but if it had been a touch longer I think it would have been more interesting. So there are a few misses for me here. Is it enough to pull me out of my reading slump? Absolutely. Check it out for the title story.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, August 18, 2020

Review: The Trouble with Peace

The Trouble with Peace The Trouble with Peace by Joe Abercrombie
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

The trouble with peace is that it does not last. People sitting idly tend to get bored. The trouble with this book is that *I* was bored.

This had been my most anticipated book of the year and ended up almost being one of the few books I did not finish. The first tenth of the book is dreadfully boring. The first half is continually boring with one of two really short moments (pages) that I enjoyed. The second half does get better especially the last quarter of the book. Twenty-Five percent of a story does not make up for the shortfalls of the rest of it.

Joe Abercrombie is very much in right now. As he has been for years. The book is going to sell well and people will worship the ground he walks on and a certain YouTuber will sing it's glory and get tons of new followers for it and life will continue as it has been. Remember, just because someone likes or dislikes something doesn't mean its bad. Out of all the books from Abercrombie that I've read, this is my least favorite and I feel it is the weakest. Is it? That's up to you to decide. He's going to make bank on it either way.

I didn't feel a thrill while reading this. Abercrombie has an ability to put you on a rollercoaster ride from the comfort of your favorite chair but I was so bored I decided to stop reading at one point and watch The Greatest Showman instead which was another dreadfully awful thing to sit through. People paid to see that so my opinion may count for nothing in the world.

I noticed that A Little Hatred gets some flak for being centered on a new generation. The Trouble With Peace, as it's the continuation, plays into that hand real hard. I didn't mind the new characters the first time around but everyone in this book came across different. Only one character ended up being likable (Orso) even though I don't remember him standing out much in the last book. He comes into his own in this one. Savine, Leo, Stour, Broad, even Rikke... I didn't care for how their development changes them. Savine and Leo especially.


One chapter about Rikke's struggles with the Long Eye allowed Abercrombie to do some creative styling with the storytelling. I guess you can say it was a chapter reversed. At first, I thought this was interesting but as the chapter dragged on I grew disenchanted. I think this is when I took my Greatest Showman sabbatical. Ugh. But don't worry because the always included continuously-changing-point-of-view-from-secondhand-characters which has become Abercrombie's trademark is here in all its typical violent glory. For those not in the know, this is when a character is stabbed, and then we follow the person doing the stabbing, then they die somehow and we follow their killer, and it goes on like this until we shift from the killers to observers and then go back to normal. When I finally got to it here I had almost forgotten he did these types of chapters.

Fans of Best Served Cold will be happy to see many connections here including what I'll call a cameo from a certain husband and wife team. I was disappointed that one of them is repeatedly mentioned when they didn't show up again in a more pivotal role. The players in this book are strictly the characters we were introduced to last time. We also learn more about Clover, who he is, and an interesting tidbit of what made him famous. I also miss Glokta centered stories. I started daydreaming at one point that maybe Abercrombie will kill him with an epic send-off. The original cast has been dead or is dying out in this trilogy but he deserves a little fan service. I keep hoping that the Bloody Nine will return even after the events of Red Country. The best ending for this new trilogy I could think of would be both Logen and Ferro returning to, pardon my language, fuck shit up. If that shit happens to be Bayaz, even better. 


Being a sequel in a series, specifically the middle book, you have to enhance the story of the original while leaving the reader wanting to get to the conclusion. For most of The Trouble With Peace the behavior of the cast was unreliable based on what I'd come to know of them previously and the main word I would use to describe the book is Wasted. The cast was wasted to tell a story of treason and betrayal that is expected, common, and unoriginal which are not words that I would normally use when Abercrombie is involved. I wanted more but got less. I had ambitious hopes but as mentioned above the only person I liked this time around was Orso. I'm not sure how Abercrombie plans to end the series and I'll read it for sure, but the days for idol worship of "Lord Grimdark" are over.

View all my reviews

Sunday, July 26, 2020

Review: Dead Man in a Ditch

Dead Man in a Ditch Dead Man in a Ditch by Luke Arnold
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

The conclusion of our two-part Luke Arnold double feature.

"I don't believe in second chances. I don't believe you can undo what was done. But if I didn't believe I still had it in me to do something good, I would have jumped out the Angel door a long time ago."

In the sequel to Luke Arnold's debut novel, he writes the story I would expect and then slaps me in the face for getting too cocky. And this after I wrote his parents that lovely letter!

For his first novel I was caught up in the joy of reading it but for this read-through, I took tons of notes and kept analyzing what was written and working out where I thought the story was headed. Despite my best efforts, I turned out shocked, then furious, then uncertain, then a whole range of other emotions as things transpired that were entirely out of my control and not in the least how I pictured the story going. The last fifth of the book strapped me to a BMX bike and said "Here, good luck!"

Well, damn.

Which isn't to say the other eighty percent of the book is predictable. I was being very critical and going "Wouldn't it be nice if..." 

Is it his background in movies and television that taught Luke how to tell a story in this manner? Dead Man In A Ditch is a perfect complete package. If I was a teacher I would give it an A++. 

You can't have a title like that and not have a worthy body count. What a delivery. After taking a one-off job for a friend, Fletch is called upon by the police department to investigate a murder that appears to be accomplished with the use of magic. Between the two novels, rumors have sprung about that Fletch is the go-to guy for magic related investigations. They say he is on a quest to bring magic back. Fletch is still in the position we last left him in, so as readers we know he isn't misleading when he says he doesn't believe he can be much help. Magic is gone from this world. 

But Magic isn't always the answer.

Where in the first book Luke Arnold wrote about a world post-magic where inhabitants are struggling to find their places in the unnatural order of things, Dead Man in a Ditch introduces us to what could technically be referred to as an industrial revolution. It is mostly behind the scenes until it's not, but Humans have been busy since the events of the Coda. Fletch takes on a multitude of cases which ultimately put him in the midst of a battle that never truly ended, just changed forms. 

Last time, we viewed the aftermath of the Coda with a grittiness. The relationships we develop this time around or interactions we witness have a deep emotional quality to them. The suffering and loss which I mostly disregarded from the first book hit home here. The part with the Faeries has me still asking questions. I'll avoid spoilers but I wish we revisit this in a sequel. 

Somewhere in Luke Arnold's house is a very worn copy of a Mythical Creature Encyclopedia or else he has a very questionable browser history. I was excited to see a Goblin have a big role that didn't involve berserker rage or banking. Then came the Succumbae who do extreme body modification and steal every scene they're in.  There's also a Unicorn used unconventionally in a scene that brings the desperation we all felt when watching *that* moment in Neverending Story. It's not what you expect. And here I cackle like a madman. 

The majority of our supporting cast is back. Warren, Ritchie, Simms, Baxter, and others. I did notice an omission who gets name dropped at the very end of the book but had no role here otherwise. It was once I sat down to write this review that I realize books one and two are distinctly different. I don't know what type of contract was signed for the series. If it's write-as-you-go or if there is a planned three to seven book saga we are journeying on.  Outside of setting up Fletch with rumors of what he investigates, certain events from book one have no other connection to this story. Which is both a relief and a curiosity. On one hand, this allows us to branch out and explore the world without being stuck with one group of creatures over another. On the other hand, it means some people are out there running around doing who knows what. We don't, but it's not important. The bigger story does carry over and it really threw me. 

I knew what the stakes were, but what a way to break a man. 

Dead Man in a Ditch takes us to the seedier parts of Sunder City. On a job about a missing person, Fletch winds up at a casino and brothel where us readers are taught a new card game. I don't know our equivalent but it sounded fun, the rules are all there, and I anxiously want to play it. I'm making the call right here: Orbit should give Luke Arnold his own author page dedicated to the series and have a playable version of the game online. You can play against other fans, take which fantasy creature are you quizzes...the internet goes crazy for that stuff. Join the Opus! Join the Army! Join the Resistance! Join the Sunder City PD! Join the Library is what my badge would be. Geeze. 

What's up with all the Werecats? 

I googled it and according to Wikipedia: Werecat folklore is found on all continents EXCEPT Antarctica and Australia and is generally based on wild felines native to the area. Did Luke watch a lot of Thundercats as a child? 

Actually, correction incoming. What I thought was Wikipedia is a website called Wiki Fur which is ahem: the free encyclopedia written by and for furries. What dark hole did the internet drop me down to come up with that one? Well, you know what, that's google's top website on the creature so they would be the experts. 

Dead Man in a Ditch takes Fletch's past and brings it guns-a-blazing into the present. The momentum is explosive. When all the pieces fall into place it is a radiant, head spinning, page-turner of a novel. But what does it mean? What does it MEAN? 

It means when we aren't looking that the rug is going to get pulled out from under us. It means not everything that was lost is completely gone. It means there's hope. While some things will never be the same again, there is still a world. There is still a city. And however it will take him, there is Fletch Philips. 

View all my reviews

Wednesday, July 22, 2020

Review: The Last Smile in Sunder City

The Last Smile in Sunder City The Last Smile in Sunder City by Luke Arnold
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

In Part I of a two-part Luke Arnold double feature, we take a trip to Sunder City. 

Believe it or not, this is one of the few noir-style detective fiction books in a fantasy setting I've ever read.* That translates as: I'm not an expert on Noir in general. I grew up with my Grandfather who lived and breathed the genre. I didn't pick up too much from him there. I understand it from a stereotypical perspective which means an office and a sultry woman who comes needing help. There's no sultry woman here. What we have is Fletch Phillips: Man for Hire. He is a human in a world that was once filled with the fantastical. We don't know that quite yet.

The use of a sex education/your changing body video to introduce us to the fantasy world was brilliant. Up until that point, the book is a generic detective noir based on my limited understanding. Fetch receives a phone call in his office and goes to the school to meet the Principal who will offer him a job. Nothing at all prepares us for the essence of the story until we watch this film and find out the bodily changes consist of fangs for the girl and stumps growing out of the boy's back. It's then revealed this is a school for fantasy creatures. The Principal himself was once a wizard. But there's no magic and being a fantasy creature is meaningless. This is also explained in the video.

You see before our story starts there was an event known as the Coda. The Humans, including Fetch as a soldier, go to the source of magic to try to harness it themselves. They fail. What they did achieve is to cause the river to crystalize, suddenly cutting off all magic in the world. Wizard's spells were useless. Dragons and Wyverns fall from the sky. Elves age hundreds of years. Vampires no longer are thwarted by the sun but they also are no longer sustained by blood. Creatures lose everything that made them what they were. Now they were, even with different bodies, on the same level as humans who are the true minorities in this world but it doesn't feel like it.

If fantasy creatures were sprinkles, this book would be very crunchy ice cream. There are Sirens, Gnomes, Dwarves, Kobolds, Ogres, Trolls, Demons, Witches, Vampires, Elves, Dragons, Werewolfs, Werecats, Wizards, Banshees, Necromancers, and more. I am not sure what possessed Luke to throw almost every possible type of creature in there but wow. At the same time, the book doesn't feel crowded by all of this. If Luke was any bit of a novice writer I would be dismayed at interaction after interaction. It sounds like too much. Luke finds a way to populate his world without choking us.

I'm sorry. I can't continue this without writing a letter to Luke's parents.

Dear Mr. and Mrs. Arnold,
It's common knowledge that you are well acquainted with Classic American movies. But are you acquainted with the classically American movie known as The Waterboy? It has a young Adam Sandler, Fairuza Balk being Fairuza Balk, and Kathy Bates does a dance routine in the background of the final Football game. It's well worth it. Towards the end of the movie, Ron Howard's naturally ugly brother Clint gives a speech to Adam's Waterboy character about how he is an inspiration to people who weren't born with natural talent, charm, or a fully functional brain. This is how I feel knowing your son is in the world. Clint breaks down crying but I will hold myself together. It is staggering that someone with this much capability and skill exists. You guys did a great job raising him.
Ever and Always, Alexander.

The detective plot revolves around a missing Vampire who is a professor of the school, and later a Siren who went to the Vampire for additional lessons. Fletch weaves through a changing cast of characters trying to solve this puzzle while also giving us insight into his background and why people react to him the way they do. He seems to have a history with almost everybody. He actually does. Without revealing it and spoiling the book, I will say that Fletch has a bigger hand in the loss of magic than is initially mentioned. His existence is one of atonement. He's not perfect. Addicted to painkillers. Hanging out in darkened bars. A little cocky and do-what-needs-to-be-done. I kept imagining Luke as Fletch. That's the benefit of having an actor for an author. He'd be perfect for it.

Of course, the mystery of those missing soon reveals a larger plot that will carry us through to the rest of the series.

In one museum scene, Fletch muses "A good man is made through a lifetime of work. Great men are made by their monsters." I love this line. He was referring to how the men who made history usually came in sets. Someone who does great deeds may or may not be remembered. Who cares about someone that does a decent or flawless job? If two enemies engage each other, they are recorded for all time. Think about it in our terms. FDR versus Hitler. Who was the president before FDR? Who rules Germany before Hitler? Who cares. It's the men in conflict we are interested in. And yet why I loved this line is because it made me think of Fletch himself. As I said, he isn't perfect but he is trying to do his best in a world that doesn't believe it needs him. At the same time, Fletch is his own monster. No matter who he faces off in future books, guilt and regret are his biggest adversaries. Men are made by their monsters.

Along with that, one of the central themes of this book is hope.

"I was fine with having nothing. Nothing to hold onto and so no reason to do anyone else any wrong. But give me a little hope and I'll show you who I really am."

"Maybe nobody gets better. Maybe bad people just get worse. It's not the bad things that make people bad, though. From what I've seen, we all work together in the face of adversity. Join up like brothers and work to overcome whatever big old evil wants to hold us down. The thing that kills us is the hope. Give a good man something to protect and you'll turn him into a killer."

See, it's the promise of hope who drives the narrative. In a world without magic, is there a chance it will come back? And what would you do in order to obtain it?

Luke Arnold, everybody. Again, wow. I had to seek this book out as I've had its sequel sitting in wait for me as I kept reading other books in my never-ending pile. When I learned who wrote Dead Men in a Ditch I decided to grab the first one. It's inconceivable how good this is. Top five of the year. Stick around for part II as I cover Dead Men in a Ditch next!!! 



*The other, of course, being the Bobby Dollar books by Tad Williams. They are Urban Fantasy Noir. The series is about the angel Doloriel who investigates as souls mysteriously go missing instead of ending up in heaven or hell. Book two has the greatest imagining of Hell that I've ever read.       

View all my reviews

Sunday, July 19, 2020

Review: The Hole

The Hole The Hole by Hiroko Oyamada
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Sometimes I love exploring a book without having any notion of what it may be about beforehand. I saw that The Hole was written by Hiroko Oyamada and wasn't a fantasy novel which is a genre I gravitate towards. It's important to step away from habits every now and then. With that little bit of information, I ventured into this novella blindly and came out thinking what the hell did I just read which is a lovely sentiment.


This is a story that will make you think. Asa and her husband relocate to an adjacent house next door to the latter's parents to be closer to his work. Moving from the city to a town, it's inconvenient in the respect that transportation is limited and without a car the options are slim. Asa leaves her job in the city for the move but is unable to acquire work right away due to her husband using their only car for his work. She spends time walking to the grocery store and napping. Sometimes she reads. She explains that she lives from meal to meal as preparing breakfast, lunch, and dinner are the only routine of each day. It's not too far off from how people currently are or were dealing with the quarantine. She's totally relatable. Asa comes across as directionless, trying to find some way to deal with her solitude. Her mother-in-law doesn't seem to like her very much, at least from what I can tell. Her husband's ninety-year-old Grandfather also lives next door with his parents. He spends his time outdoors watering the Garden. Or flooding it, rather.

Asa's life changes when her Mother in Law asks her to run an errand and she comes across a large animal. It's never stated what the animal is. It's big like a dog, but it's not a weasel or a raccoon. She follows it and ends up falling into a Hole. It's not too deep of a hole. Only 5 feet and her head sticks out level with the grass.

From this point on the book becomes highly open to interpretation. She is helped out of the hole by the neighbor that lives on the other side of her In-laws. It's hard to say exactly what is real and what is made up in Asa's head. Are the creature and the hole a metaphor for her own isolation and her interest in it an attempt to give meaning to her stunted life? I would say most likely yes. Later on in the story, the neighbor visits and mentions a name that was not her husband's. She corrects herself but after this slip-up, Asa meets a brother she never knew her husband had. He is not mentioned or referenced by anyone else in the family. I'm convinced he isn't real. I'll leave that for you to decide but the ending with her discovery of the Shed's condition, which is where the brother in law lives, convinces me I'm correct. He is similarly in the same situation as Asa. Someone who lives in isolation due to the decisions they have made.

There's also a pattern relating to children. Asa's coworker before she leaves her job asks her if she's going to be a housewife and get pregnant. She has multiple run-ins with children in situations involving her brother-in-law. Its almost like she's projecting having a child as an excuse to prove she's worthy of existing. Asa has to figure out what is going on with the town, the animals, the mysterious brother in law, and the truth about the family she married into.

Unfortunately, this being a Novella I feel talking more about it would require me to write the whole book here. It was very short. I'm hesitant to even call it a Novella. It took me around an hour to read it so if you are looking for something that is quick and makes you think, then this would work out well. I love how it is open to interpretation.

View all my reviews